I am not a fanboy.
I am a Fan MAN.
And that means I know what good writing and good characterization has done for super hero films, making them as emotionally powerful on screen as they were in our little minds and hearts way back in the day when comics were still sold for twenty-cents at Seven-Eleven Stores.
There is a reason Superman the Movie will never be topped and there is a reason the Fantastic Four movie sucked all kinds of eggs. The first was written by men who were going to tell us a mythical story and fable that touched all our hearts and minds but the second was corporate gang bang with no emotional depth whatsoever. Someone listened WAY too long to the Marketing Department on THAT piece of trash -and to the dumb little fanboys - who also ruined Spider-Man 3 with their childish demands for Venom.
Avi Arad should be ashamed of himself.
They ARE re-booting Fantastic Four, thank God, and I will tell you what they need to get IT right in the next blog [hint: Dr. Doom's origin is the key, NOT the FF's].
As for re-booting Spider-Man? STOOOO-PIDDD. Raimi was and is still the Man. But let's move on, shall we?
OK, we all agree that Christopher Nolan has rescued the Batman franchise from stupidity and campiness in just TWO movies, right? I mean, NOTHING is further from the 60's camp than The Dark Knight, right? Right.
It's because he's not here to make a 'Batman' film but a film about a man who refuses to lay down and let evil rule him. Lots of hard-working artists worked on this film, and it shows. [They were merely following wisely in the footsteps of Denny O'Neil and Neal Adams who gave us back the World's Greatest Detective in the early 70's...]
I'm listening to the TDK SOUNDTRACK for the 28th time, and I tell you kids, next to John William's epic score for The Empire Strikes Back and Superman, no one comes close to nailing pathos, heroism and nerve wracking tension. Just an A+ piece of music. Sweet Lord Almighty, it makes the Batman Begins soundtrack sound like a warm-up.
Let us say that there are artists who can draw, and artists who can create, and then there are artists who just slap your face into the dirt, walk over you and make you gasp for air. It's like discovering Michael Golden all over again. Nolan is to film what Golden was to comics back in the day. Seriously.
Now all that gushing out of the way, I've got to speak my peace and put my ideas out for Batman 3 BEFORE it happens, so everyone can be praying hard that Nolan does something EVEN MORE WONDERFUL after creating lightning in a bottle with TDK.
First, do keep in mind Nolan wants to end his Batman arc here. No Batman 4 for him. So Batman 3 must either be a huge tragedy or a terrific legacy, cause the 'Nolan Tales of the Bat', she be ending. And we have established, "you either die a hero, or you end up a villain."
Secondly, according to rumors, will we have a good 'could exist in the real world' villain - The Riddler. With movies like Silence of the Lambs and Se7en to draw inspiration from, including his own work, Memento, Nolan is going to play HARD with a villain who wants to tease Batman and prove he is his superior, risking lives along the way.
Thirdly, with Rachel dead and Harvey Dent dead/absent, Bruce Wayne will be suffering in an emotional vacuum and social dissonance. He will NEED another love interest and possible 'believer' that supports his war on crime. He will crave a woman who is strong-willed yet able to handle herself.
He will want someone to mentor and inspire, though he may not admit it. Batman has been an inspiration to Gotham City - but what does it inspire them to do, those who NOW want to wear masks? Would it inspire one to DEFY the police [as Batman is an outlaw] and yet another, to try and take justice into his own hand [as Batman has reportedly done].
So two people come in his life to fill these gaps - Catwoman [Frank Miller style from Batman: Year One] and Robin [a teen boy, on the verge of manhood, who saw his parents murdered after they refused to pay protection to the mob.
Or even better... they were killed by the Riddler while performing, as a 'test' of Batman. In the original story Bruce Wayne is merely watching the circus when Grayson's folks are killed. "Question: when does a bird fly? When it leaves its perch. When does a parrot stop talking? When its an ex-parrot. Last, what bird is the most cocky?"
In a Nolan version, Wayne could have figured out the riddle ["A 'cock-robin'], and simply was unable to move fast enough in time to save them. Thus, in guilt, he takes the boy Dick Grayson, i.e. 'Robin' in. Dick lives only a few days at the mansion before he drives off to get revenge. Batman stops him - but promises justice will be done. Great opportunity for some heart-wrenching dialogue, with a semi-masked Robin in his circus tights telling Batman off for failing to protect the innocent. Bruce would know it was because he was getting self-absorbed and makes the boy an offer - that they work together, and he, for his part, will supply the teen with everything he needs to fight crime - past getting justice on his parent's killers.
Grayson agrees and become Robin - but we use a Princess Bride style mask for our swashbuckling teen wonder, and more of a cloak/hood combo perhaps.
Fourthly, the battle here will be mostly on the Batman as a savior of Gotham who wants to leave an enduring legacy. In this vein, we could start the movie with "10 Years Later" to show he's been trying to make an impact; he's winning the battle but he's losing the war.
Fifthly, if Robin does come in, and Batman is 'finished', he can end up taking Batman's mantle - just as he recently did in the books in Batman R.I.P.
We might even see the death of Batman. And if Selina Kyle is a love interest, but somehow was responsible for his downfall, we could end the movie with her meeting Batman's successor - i.e. Dick Grayson and state "You aren't him."
"You can never be him, you know?"
"I know. But he was a symbol - incorruptible, everlasting. A sign that good men do not need to be afraid of the dark. A warrior who brought hope when there was no hope left."
"Do you hate me - for what happened to him?"
"No - he did what he thought was right. That's what he always did."
Then we CUT HARD to the funeral and graveside. The Riddler cannot resist coming to see Batman dead - for now he knows Bruce Wayne is Batman. He's mingled in the crowd and then - is last to leave, just as it begins to rain. "What do you call a dead billionaire? An ex-Batman!" Hahahahahahahahaahaahahhaa!"
Fifthly, and then, in typical Nolan fashion, we turn the tables in the last 60 seconds of the film. Batman appears ALIVE AND KICKING and beats the living hell out of the Riddler, sending him off to Arkham, fully insane because, as he says, "You were DEAD - and there ain't no coming back!! I killed you!"
Sixthly, its Alfred Pennyworth who steps forward and delivers the punch line. He says to Batman, "It worked like a charm, sir. With Bruce Wayne dead, he could not have expected Batman to appear. He must be wondering if he's gone mad!"
And Batman growls, "I don't wonder. I know."
"You do, sir? And what precisely do you know?"
"I know who I am and who Batman is. And what legacy he can leave behind..."
And as he goes to take off his cowl, we CUT HARD TO...
What's the title?
Title: Batman: Legacy, of course.
Here's to Christopher Nolan, Jonathan Nolan, David S. Goyer and everyone who will work on this.
May the Lord give you great wisdom.